1st Ed: p132, q50, 2nd Ed: p154, q50 MODIFIED. Given
evaluate
. Also evaluate, presumably using
polar coordinates,
where path I is the semi circle of radius
going clockwise from
to
, and path II is the semi circle of radius
going counter-clockwise from
to
. Explain why the
integral over II minus the integral over I is the integral over the
closed circle. Explain why Stokes implies that the closed contour
integral should be the integral of the
-compont of
over the inside of the circle. Then explain
why you would then normally expect the contour integral to be zero.
That means that the two integrals I and II should be equal, but they
are not. Explain what the problem is.
Do you expect integrals over closed contours of different radii to
be equal? Why? Are they equal?
Now assume that you allow singular functions to be OK, like
Heaviside step functions and Dirac delta functions say. Then figure
out in what part of the interior of the circle,
is not zero. So how
would you describe
for this vector field in
terms of singular functions?